Negotiating Alternative Masculinities in Men’s Magazines: Transitivity in the Formation of Counter Hegemonic Identities
Abstract
With social transformation and male empowerment, the archetypes of traditional masculinity are being deconstructed and rendered obsolete. The changing view of masculinity demands for an exploration of how popular media, particularly men’s magazines rewrite the discourse of masculinity. Attempting to answer the overarching question of ‘what does masculinity mean today?’, this paper explores identity as a linguistic phenomenon. Drawing on both Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) and Halliday’s Transitivity system of the Systemic Functional Linguistic (SFL) frameworks, we examine ideational meanings realised by lexicogrammatical selections and discourse-semantic-choice involving process types and participants’ role that form counter hegemonic masculinities. This study argues that as men negotiate their identities, magazines play a critical role in challenging patriarchal masculinity and normalising alternative masculine practices via ideologies embedded in a text. The investigation focuses on how transitivity is drawn on to produce counter hegemonic formations and how different enactments of masculinities are articulated in magazine texts to present alternative forms of male identities. Drawing from 584,600-word corpus of selected men’s magazines titles published from 2016 to 2020, findings revealed the use of material, mental, relational and behavioural processes that manifests counter hegemonic identities or non-traditional representation. Evidence from the corpus reflects various projections of men as emotionally vulnerable, aesthetically conscious, domestically competent and antihomophobic. The implication highlights the different ways media language creates and facilitates the changes in masculine practices and how magazine texts infuse or indoctrinate alternative identities as a stable performance of masculinity.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Alameda-Hernández, Á. (2008). SFL and CDA: Contributions of the analysis of the transitivity system in the study of the discursive construction of national identity (case study: Gibraltar). The Linguistics Journal, 3(3), 160-175.
Anderson, E. (2009). Inclusive masculinity: The changing nature of masculinities. London: Routledge.
Anderson, E., & McCormack, M. (2018). Inclusive masculinity theory: Overview, reflection and refinement. Journal of Gender Studies, 27(5), 547-561.
Bartley, L.V. (2017). Transitivity, no stone left unturned: Introducing flexibility and granularity into the framework for the analysis of courtroom discourse. Unpublished
doctoral dissertation. University de Granada
Benwell, B. (2003).Ambiguous masculinities: heroism and anti-heroism in the men’s lifestyle magazine. In Masculinity and Men’s Lifestyle Magazines, 151-168. Oxford:
Blackwell.
Benwell, B. & Stokoe, E. (2006). Discourse and Identity. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 4(3), 261-262.
Biber, D., Connor, U., & Upton, T. (2007). Discourse on the Move: Using corpus analysis to describe discourse structure. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
Bozkurt, V., Tartanoglu, S., & Dawes, G. (2015). Masculinity and violence: Sex roles and violence endorsement among university students. Procedia-Social and
Behavioural Sciences, 205, 254-260.
Brescoll, V. L., & Uhlmann, E. L. (2008). Can an angry woman get ahead? Status conferral, gender, and expression of emotion in the workplace. Psychological science,
(3), 268-275.
Brod, H. (2018). The Making of Masculinities (Routledge Revivals): The New Men's Studies. New York: Routledge.
Butler, J. (2011). Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity. London: Routledge.
Cabosky, J. (2015). “For Your Consideration” A Critical Analysis of LGBT-Themed Film Award Campaign Advertisements: 1990–2005. Journalism History, 41(2), 73-84.
Carabí, À., & Armengol, J. (Eds.). (2014). Alternative masculinities for a changing world. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Connell, R. W. (1987). Gender and power. Sydney: Allen and Unwin.
Connell, R.W. (1995). Masculinities. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press
Connell, R. W. (2002). On hegemonic masculinity and violence: Response to Jefferson and Hall. Theoretical criminology, 6(1), 89-99.
Connell, R. W., & Messerschmidt, J. W. (2005). Hegemonic masculinity: Rethinking the concept. Gender & society, 19(6), 829-859.
Dhaenens, F. (2013). Teenage queerness: negotiating heteronormativity in the representation of gay teenagers in Glee. Journal of Youth Studies, 16(3), 304-317.
Donaldson, M. (1993). What is hegemonic masculinity?. Theory and society, 22(5), 643-657
Espelage, D. L., Hong, J. S., Merrin, G. J., Davis, J. P., Rose, C. A., & Little, T. D. (2018). A longitudinal examination of homophobic name-calling in middle school:
Bullying, traditional masculinity, and sexual harassment as predictors. Psychology of violence, 8(1), 57-66.
Fairclough, N. (1989). Language and power. London and New York: Longman.
Foucault, M. (1972). The Archaeology of Knowledge (A.M. Sheridan Smith, Trans.). New York: Pantheon Books.
Fowler, R. (1991). Language in the News: Discourse and Ideology in the Press. London and New York: Routledge.
Gattario, K. H., Frisén, A., Fuller-Tyszkiewicz, M., Ricciardelli, L. A., Diedrichs, P. C., Yager, Z., & Smolak, L. (2015). How is men’s conformity to masculine norms
related to their body image? Masculinity and muscularity across Western countries. Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 16(3), 337.
Gough, B., Hall, M., & Seymour-Smith, S. (2014). Straight guys do wear make-up: Contemporary masculinities and investment in appearance. In S. Roberts (Ed.),
Debating modern masculinities: Change, continuity, crisis? (pp. 106-124). London: Palgrave Pivot.
Gramsci, A. (1971). Selections from the Prison Notebooks (Q. Hoare & G.N., Smith, Eds. & Trans.) New York: International Publishers
Granato, S. L., Smith, P. N., & Selwyn, C. N. (2015). Acquired capability and masculine gender norm adherence: Potential pathways to higher rates of male suicide.
Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 16(3), 246–253. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0038181
Halliday, M. A., & Matthiessen, C. M. (1994). 32004. An Introduction to Functional Grammar. London: Arnold.
Halliday, M., & Matthiessen, C. (2014). An introduction to functional grammar. Arbingdon: Routledge.
Harper, P. B. (1998). Are we not men?: Masculine anxiety and the problem of African-American identity. Modern Fiction Studies, 44 (4), 993-995.
Hatfield, E. F. (2010). “What it means to be a man”: Examining hegemonic masculinity in Two and a Half Men. Communication, Culture & Critique, 3(4), 526-548.
Holmqvist & Gjörup, L. (2006). The Representation of Gender and Gender Roles in English Textbooks [Doctoral dissertation, Malmö University]
Horrocks, R. (1994). Masculinity in crisis. Self & Society, 22(4), 25-29.
Hunter, S. C., Riggs, D. W., & Augoustinos, M. (2017). Hegemonic masculinity versus a caring masculinity: Implications for understanding primary caregiving fathers.
Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 11(3), e12307.
Judge, T. A., Livingston, B. A., & Hurst, C. (2012). Do nice guys—and gals—really finish last? The joint effects of sex and agreeableness on income. Journal of
personality and social psychology, 102(2), 390-407.
Kaufman, M. (1994). Men, feminism, and men’s contradictory experiences of power. Theorizing masculinities, 142-165.
Kaya, A., Iwamoto, D. K., Brady, J., Clinton, L., & Grivel, M. (2019). The role of masculine norms and gender role conflict on prospective well-being among men.
Psychology of Men & Masculinities, 20(1), 142- 147.
Kimmel, M. S. (2018). The contemporary “crisis” of masculinity in historical perspective. In Harry, B. (Ed.), The Making of Masculinities (pp. 121-153). London:
Routledge.
Kluch, Y. (2015). ‘The man your man should be like’: Consumerism, patriarchy and the construction of twenty-first-century masculinities in 2010 and 2012 Old Spice
campaigns. Interactions: Studies in Communication & Culture, 6(3), 361-377.
Lavelle, K. L. (2020). The Face of Mental Health: Kevin Love and Hegemonic Masculinity in the NBA. Communication & Sport, 2167479520922182
Lee, J. Y., & Lee, S. J. (2018). Caring is masculine: Stay-at-home fathers and masculine identity. Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 19(1), 47-58.
Lee, J. J., Lee, R. K. Y., & Park, J. H. (2020). Unpacking K-pop in America: The Subversive Potential of Male K-pop Idols’ Soft Masculinity. International Journal of
Communication, 14, 5901-5919.
Leader, C. F. (2019). Dadvertising: Representations of fatherhood in Procter & Gamble’s Tide commercials. Communication Culture & Critique, 12(1), 72-89.
Luyt, R., & Foster, D. (2001). Hegemonic masculine conceptualisation in gang culture. South African Journal of Psychology, 31(3), 1-11.
Manchin, D., & Mayr, A. (2012). How to do Critical Discourse Analysis. New York: Sage Publications
Marshall, D., Davis, T., Hogg, M. K., Schneider, T., & Petersen, A. (2014). From overt provider to invisible presence: Discursive shifts in advertising portrayals of the
father in Good Housekeeping, 1950–2010. Journal of Marketing Management, 30(15-16), 1654-1679.
McInroy, L. B., & Craig, S. L. (2017). Perspectives of LGBTQ emerging adults on the depiction and impact of LGBTQ media representation. Journal of Youth Studies,
(1), 32-46.
Mikorski, R., & Szymanski, D. M. (2017). Masculine norms, peer group, pornography, Facebook, and men’s sexual objectification of women. Psychology of Men &
Masculinity, 18(4), 257-267.
Möller, E. L., Majdandžić, M., & Bögels, S. M. (2015). Parental anxiety, parenting behaviour, and infant anxiety: Differential associations for fathers and mothers.
Journal of Child and Family Studies, 24(9), 2626-2637.
Orloff, J. (2017). The Empath's Survival Guide: Life Strategies for Sensitive People. Louisville: Sounds True.
Padgett, J. K. (2017). Mapping alternative masculinities: Development, validation, and latent profile analysis of a new masculinity measure. [Dissertation, University of
Western Ontario]. Electronic thesis and dissertation repository.
Peterson, D. (2016). Homophobic grammar: The role of transitivity and phoricity in homophobic formation. Journal of Language and Sexuality, 5(1), 61-93.
Ramaeker, J., & Petrie, T. A. (2019). “Man up!” Exploring intersections of sport participation, masculinity, psychological distress, and help-seeking attitudes and
intentions. Psychology of Men & Masculinities, 20(4), 515.
Ricciardelli, R., Clow, K. A., & White, P. (2010). Investigating hegemonic masculinity: Portrayals of masculinity in men’s lifestyle magazines. Sex Roles, 63(1-2), 64-
Rosette, A. S., Mueller, J. S., & Lebel, R. D. (2015). Are male leaders penalized for seeking help? The influence of gender and asking behaviours on competence
perceptions. The Leadership Quarterly, 26(5), 749-762.
Schmitz, R. M. (2016). Constructing men as fathers: A content analysis of formulations of fatherhood in parenting magazines. The Journal of Men’s studies, 24(1), 3-
Schwartz, J., & Andsager, J. L. (2011). Four decades of images in gay male-targeted magazines. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 88(1), 76-98.
Simpson, M. (1994). Here come the mirror men: Metrosexual men wear Paul Smith, use moisturizer, and know that vanity begins at home. The Independent.
Retrieved December 12, 2020 from http://www.marksimpson.com/pages/journalism/mirror_men.html.
Snell, W. E. (1986). The masculine role inventory: Components and correlates. Sex Roles, 15(7-8), 443-455.
Sonnekus, T., & Van Eeden, J. (2009). Visual representation, editorial power, and the dual ‘othering’ of black men in the South African gay press: The case of Gay
Pages. Communication: South African Journal for Communication Theory and Research, 35(1), 81-100.
Stich, D.M. (2015, May 12). Guys are more vain than women. Metro. https://metro.co.uk/2015/05/12/guys-are-more-vain-than-women-we-knew-it-5193026/
Thurman, N., & Fletcher, R. (2020). Effects of a magazine’s move to online-only: Post-print audience attention and readership retention revisited. Journalism Practice,
(10), 1225-1243.
Way, N., Cressen, J., Bodian, S., Preston, J., Nelson, J., & Hughes, D. (2014). “It might be nice to be a girl... Then you wouldn’t have to be emotionless”: Boys'
resistance to norms of masculinity during adolescence. Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 15(3), 241-252.
Williams, K. E., & Koleva, H. (2018). Identification and treatment of peripartum anxiety disorders. Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clinics, 45(3), 469-481
Wodak, R. (2001). What CDA is about: A summary of its history, important concepts and its developments. In R. Wodak & M. Meyer (Eds.), Methods of critical
discourse analysis (pp. 1–13). London: Sage Publications.
Yang, H. C. (2014). Flower boys on campus: Performing and practicing masculinity. Journal of Gender Studies, 23(4), 391-408.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17576/gema-2021-2102-08
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
eISSN : 2550-2131
ISSN : 1675-8021