The prevalence of defective vehicles, or “lemons,” in the Malaysian automotive market continues to raise concerns despite the existence of consumer protection laws. This study aims to investigate the efficacy of Malaysia’s consumer protection laws in addressing this persistent issue and examine the potential impact of adopting Lemon Laws in Malaysia. Employing a doctrinal methodology, the study examines statutes, case laws, and scholarly literatures to offer a detailed understanding of the current legal landscape and the mechanics of Lemon Laws in selected jurisdictions. The research undertakes a comprehensive analysis of relevant legislation, including but not limited to the Malaysian Consumer Protection Act 1999 to identify potential limitations and areas for improvement. It further explores the concept of “Lemon Laws,” successfully implemented in various jurisdictions, and assesses their potential applicability within the Malaysian context. The research findings advocate for the strategic amendment of the existing Consumer Protection Act 1999 to incorporate provisions analogous to Lemon Laws, thereby strengthening consumer rights and nurturing a more equitable and transparent automotive marketplace in Malaysia.

Keywords: Consumer protection; automotive industry; lemon law; defective product; Consumer Protection Act 1999

References

Abdullah, F., Chin, O. T., Na'aim, M. S. M., & Dayatie, N. H. (2019). Legislative enforcement of contractual fairness in Malaysian consumer contracts. Journal of ASIAN Behavioural Studies, 4(13), 51-61.

Abdullah, H. (2009). Good Faith, Fair-Dealing and Disclosure Requirements in Hire-Purchase Contracts in Malaysia: Islamic and conventional Perspectives. Journal of Islam in Asia, 6(1), 123-148.

Adams, A. (2021, August 12). Lemon Law 101: Understanding the Law and Your Rights. BBB National Programs. https://bbbprograms.org/media-center/bd/insights/2021/08/12/lemon-law-101

Aiman, A. (2024, January 18). Govt mulling ‘lemon law’ after complaints of problems with new cars. Free Malaysia Today. https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2024/01/18/govt-mulling-lemon-law-after-complaints-of-problems-with-new-cars/

Al Sagoff, S. S., & Ismail, R. (2017). Consumer Protection and Product Safety in ASEAN: A Development of ASEAN General Product Safety Directive. Jurnal Undang-undang dan Masyarakat, 2017(S).

Amin, N. & Bakar, E.A. (2012). The Adequacy of Remedies in Consumer Transactions: Special Study in the Motor Vehicle Repair and Service Industry in Malaysia. Malaysian Journal of Consumer and Family Economics, 15(2), 39-53.

Amin, N. (2013). Protecting Consumers Against Unfair Contract Terms in Malaysia: The Consumer Protection (Amendment) Act 2010. Malayan Law Journal, 1, 89.

Amin, N. (1999). Product liability under the Consumer Protection Act 1999. IIUM Law Journal, 7(2), 175- 198

Anbalagan, V. (2014, Oct 13). Have ‘lemon law’ to protect car buyers, says consumer group. The Edge Markets. https://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/have-%E2%80%98lemon-law%E2%80%99-protect-car-buyers-says-consumer-group.

Anbalagan, V. (2021, Feb 15). Court awards RM90,000 to company unable to use faulty new car. Free Malaysia Today. https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2021/02/15/court-awards-rm90000-to-company-unable-to-use-faulty-new-car/

Azman, M. (2024, January 16). Vehicle Sales Reached New All-Time High in 2023 – MAA. Carz Automedia. https://www.carz.com.my/2024/01/vehicle-sales-reached-new-all-time-high-in-2023-maa

Barron, N. (1989). California's Lemon Law-Developments under the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act. Loy. Consumer L. Rep., 2, 96.

Benjamin, J. P. (2012). Benjamin's sale of goods (Vol. 11). Sweet & Maxwell.

Bernama (2024a, March 18). Study on lemon law’s effectiveness to consider loopholes in Act 599. The Sun. https://thesun.my/local-news/study-on-lemon-law-s-effectiveness-to-consider-loopholes-in-act-599-AC12231122

Bernama. (2024b, July 3). In Dewan Rakyat today: Lemon law challenges, military camp relocation, dual 5G network status. Malay Mail. https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2024/07/03/in-dewan-rakyat-today-lemon-law-challenges-military-camp-relocation-dual-5g-network-status/142548

Bernama. (2024c, July 16). MAA revises up 2024 vehicle sales forecast to 765,000 units. Bernama News. https: //www.bernama.com/en/business/news.php?id=2318113
California Civil Code. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displayText.xhtml?lawCode=CIV&division=3.&title=1.7.&part=4.&chapter=1.&article=3.

Chan, Y.S. (2021, April 4). Fine-tune the Consumer Protection Act 1999 to protect travel agents. Malaysiakini. https://www.malaysiakini.com/letters/569401.

Cheong, P.Y. (2022, March 28). MAA: Prices Of CKD Cars May Go Up By 8% To 20% In 2023. Ringgit Plus. https://ringgitplus.com/en/blog/personal-finance-news/maa-prices-of-ckd-cars-may-go-up-by-8-to-20-in-2023.html#:~:text=The%20Malaysian%20Automotive%20Association%20(MAA,slated%20to%20begin%20next%20year.

Cheong, M. F., & Lee, Y. H. (2022). Contracts resulting from threats and unfair exploitation: The position under Malaysian Contract Law. In M. Chen-Wishart, H. Sono, & S. Vogenauer (Eds.), Invalidity (pp. 271-288). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780192859341.003.0015

Chin, O. T., & Yusoff, S. S. A. (2017). Malaysia and Singapore. International Business Management, 100(6), 1328-1335.

Channel News Asia. (2012, March 9). “Lemon law” passed in Parliament. Channel News Asia. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/lemon-law-passed-parliament-1891446.

Code of Federal Regulation. (2024, September 24). E-CFR.gov. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-G/part-703
Consumer Association of Penang. (2019, Feb 15). New car buyers need protection. Consumer.org. https://consumer.org.my/new-car-buyers-need-protection/

Corones, S. (2016). Why Australia needs a motor vehicle “lemon” law. The University of New South Wales Law Journal, 39(2), 625-657.

Daim, N. (2013, December 6). 36.3 million vehicles in Malaysia. New Straits Times. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2023/12/987062/363-million-vehicles-malaysia

Davies, I. (1995). The Ostensible Ownership Dilemma and Motor Vehicle Financing a Common Law Dilemma? IIUMLJ, 5, 99.

Ervine, W. C. H. (1985). Protecting New Car Purchasers: Recent United States and English Developments Compared. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 34 (2), 342-358.

Federation of Malaysian Consumers Association. (2021, April 1). Consumers left in unfavourable position. Federation of Malaysian Consumers Association. https://www.fomca.org.my/v1/index.php/fomca-di-pentas-media/consumer-digest/1312-consumers-left-in-unfavourable-position

FMT Reporters. (2023, October 27). NCCC calls for ‘lemon law’ after complaints of defective cars. Free Malaysia Today. https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2023/10/27/nccc-calls-for-lemon-law-after-complaints-of-defective-cars/

Herrera, J. (2021, September 28). Resolving Lemon Law Disputes. BBB National Programs. https://bbbprograms.org/media-center/bd/insights/2021/09/28/resolving-lemon-law-disputes

Ibrahim Ali, S., Mohamed Yusoff, Z., & Ayub, Z. A. (2017). Legal Research of Doctrinal and Non-Doctrinal. International Journal of Trend in Research and Development, 4(1), 493 - 495.

Jan, M. N. I., Mohamed, A. A. A., & Ali, A. (2010). Mediation in Malaysia: The law and practice. Selangor: LexisNexis.
Jayabalan, S. & Randawar, D.K. (2017). The Role of The Modern Contract Law in The Purview of Consumer Protection. Jurnal Intelek, 12(1), 21-27.

Kirkizoğlu, Z., & Karaer, Ö. (2022). After-sales service and warranty decisions of a durable goods manufacturer. Omega, 113, 102719. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2022.102719

Lai, A. (2024, March 15). Govt should consider introducing Lemon Law for defective products, says consumer group. The Star. https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2024/03/15/govt-should-consider-introducing-lemon-law-for-defective-products-says-consumer-group

Lim, J. (2016, January 22). More used-car dealers sour over lemon law. The Straits Times. https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/transport/more-used-car-dealers-sour-over-lemon-law.

Lee, M. P., Samen, D., & Detta, I. J. (2020). Commercial law in Malaysia. Lexis Nexis.

Lexology. (2024, August 1). What Is a Lemon? Understanding Defective Vehicles. Lexology. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=7e0b8831-2368-4c0b-88e2-521f3badc3cd

Loke, A. F. (2014). The lemon law and the integrated enhancement of consumer rights in Singapore. Singapore Journal of Legal Studies, 285-306.

Looi, S. (2024, January 4). Perodua under fire over response to customer whose car broke down just eight hours after taking possession. Malay Mail. https://www.malaymail.com/news/life/2024/01/04/perodua-under-fire-over-response-to-customer-whose-car-broke-down-just-eight-hours-after-taking-possession/110552.

Malaysian Automotive Association. (2023). Summary of new passenger & commercial vehicles registered in Malaysia for the year 2010 to 2023. https://www.maa.org.my/statistics.html

Malaysian Investment Development Authority. (2023). Malaysia: your Southeast Asian automotive hub. Malaysian Investment Development Authority. https://www.mida.gov.my/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/1.-Automotive-SIB-2022-2023.pdf

Masum, A., Ahmad, M.H., Nafees, S.M.M. & Md Isa, Y. (2018). Consumer Protection for Sale of Goods under the Malaysian Sale of Goods Act 1957 and the Consumer Protection Act 1999: With Special Reference to Quality and Fitness of Goods. American Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences Research, 2(6), 44-52.

Masum, A., Md Dahlan, N. H., Nafees, S. M., & Kyaw, H. W. (2015, November 16-19). Consumer protection for sale of goods: A Malaysian perspective [Paper presentation]. Proceedings of the AGBA 12th Annual World Congress, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

Miller, C. (2023, August 16). California’s Lemon Law: the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act. Heygood, Oar & Pearson. https://www.hop-law.com/california-lemon-law-song-beverly-act/#:~:text=A%20provision%20of%20the%20Song,can%20be%20deemed%20a%20lemon.

Mohamed Radhi, N.A. & Sallehuddin, Q. (2024, March 1). Feasibility study on ‘lemon law’ for vehicles ongoing. New Straits Times. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2024/03/1027715/feasibility-study-lemon-law-vehicles-ongoing

Naseer, S. (2017, Feb 17). We need the Lemon law. The Star Online. https://www.thestar.com.my/opinion/letters/2017/01/27/we-need-the-lemon-law/#1PbfbuMU0TzyEOci.99.

Ng, F. (2024, July 12). Of lemons and cars. The Star Online. https://www.thestar.com.my/business/business-news/2024/07/12/of-lemons-and-cars

Paterson, J. M., & Wong, V. (2016). Consumer protection, statute and the ongoing influence of the general law in Singapore. Singapore Academy of Law Journal, 28, 1079-1110.

Sabri, M. F. (2014). The development of consumer protection policies in Malaysia. International Journal of Business and Social Research, 4(6), 98-108.

Saidin, Z. H., Rahman, W. A. W. A., Nafi, S. N. M., Saad, R., & Mokhtar, S. S. M. (2022). Examining industry-specific after-sales service quality towards the level of customer loyalty: A case of Malaysian national carmakers. Ebangi: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 19(4), 70-93.

Safei, S. & Abdullah, N.C. (2023). A new proposed features of Malaysian legal framework for alternative dispute resolution in the tribunal for consumer claims. ESTEEM Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 7 (2). pp. 71-83. ISSN 2600-7274.

Singapore Consumer Protection (Fair Trading) Act 2003. (rev. 2020). Singapore Statutes Online. https://sso.agc.gov.sg/Act/CPFTA2003

Vong, Y. (2024, March 11). ‘Lemon law’ needed more urgently than ever. Free Malaysia Today. https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/opinion/2024/03/11/lemon-law-needed-more-urgently-than-ever/

Wahab, M. A., Jawi, Z. M., Hamid, I. A., Solah, M. S., Latif, M. M., Isa, M. M. & Hamzah, A. (2017). Automotive consumerism in Malaysia with regard to car maintenance. Journal of the Society of Automotive Engineers Malaysia, 1(2), 137-153.

Yusoff, S.S.A., Ismail, R., Aziz, A.A., Isa, S.M., & Talib, K. A. (2013). Consumer contracts of sale of goods: The legal dilemma in Malaysia. Malaysian Journal of Consumer and Family Economics, 16, 29-42

Zainul, E. (2024, February 21). Sime Darby to increase car prices following service tax hike. The Edge Malaysia. https://theedgemalaysia.com/node/701769

Zainuddin, M. Z. (2024, January 5). The process of replacing Nagakanni’s Bezza far from straightforward, says lawyer. New Straits Times. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2024/01/997760/process-replacing-nagakannis-bezza-far-straightforward-says-lawyer.

Zakuan, Z. Z. M., & Yusoff, S. S. A. (2013). Liability of manufacturer for goods under the Consumer Protection Act 1999: A paradigm shift. Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization, 11, 31.